Tuesday, 30 March 2010

Hidden Healthcare Gems

I have not (and probably will not) taken the time to read the two pieces of legislation that passed Congress last week and which are generically being called Healthcare Reform, but fortunately others who have an interest in employment law are doing so. Although in many ways the whole bill is very much an employment law bill because of the impact on employee benefits, some portions of it are more employment law related. 
The top two that have been found so far:
Since it appears that the Fair Labor Standards Act was the vehicle of choice for many employment law related aspectes, a quick scan of the texts for that statute found the following:

In H.R. 3590 [pdf] (the Senate Bill that was passed by the House without change):
  • Sec. 1511 - automatic enrollment (into health benefit plans) for employees of large employers (200 full time employees);
  • Sec. 15122 - Requirement of all employers to inform employee of coverage options, including the existence of the newly created Exchanges;
  • Sec. 1588 - Protections for employees, the whistleblowing statutes that Jason Zuckerman wrote about;
  • Sec. 4207 - Reasonable break time for nursing mothers that Jon Hyman found.
The "fix-it" bill, H.R. 4872 [pdf] which may be signed into law today, has no references to the FLSA.

Sunday, 28 March 2010

It's Here: The Obama Board

Although it took longer than expected, and required using the recess appointment mechanism, Saturday's expected announcement that Craig Becker and Mark Pearce would be appointed to the Board marks the transition to an Obama majority on the NLRB. President Obama Announces Recess Appointments to Key Administration Positions. The fifth potential member, Republican Bryan Hayes'nomination is still pending in the Senate (the Becker and Pearce nominations remain as well.)

Also on the list of the 15 recess appointments are three members of the EEOC, Jaqueline A. Berrien as Chair, Chai R. Feldblum and Victoria A. Lipnic as members. P. David Lopez  receives a recess appointment as General Counsel. Of those, Feldblum was the one who had drawn the most attention.

Because these recess appointments will expire when the Senate adjourns in December, 2011, it will be interesting to see how quickly they begin acting. Given the length of time the Board has been operating with only two members, and thus deciding only those cases where Democratic and Republican members could agree, there is a substantial backlog of cases to be decided. Additionally, there has been much talk about the possibility of rule making to accomplish at least some of the objectives of the legislatively stalled Employee Free Choice Act.

As a reminder of some of the changes that could be coming check out the monograph prepared by two of my colleagues, Hal and Chris Coxson, The National Labor Relations Board in the Obama Administration: What Changes to Expect.

If you had put off getting up to speed about what would happen with an Obama Board, time is up. For better or worse, it is here.

Friday, 26 March 2010

Four Pillars for Immigration Reform

Having just finished with one hot potato, at least two Senators are ready to tackle yet another. And surprisingly enough, it is a bi-partisan effort. In a Washington Post opinion piece, Charles E. Schumer and Lindsey O. Graham - The right way to mend immigration offer four premises on which any new legislation should be based:
Our plan has four pillars:
    • requiring biometric Social Security cards to ensure that illegal workers cannot get jobs;
    • fulfilling and strengthening our commitments on border security and interior enforcement;
    • creating a process for admitting temporary workers;
    • and implementing a tough but fair path to legalization for those already here.
Obviously, the biometric card will set off concerns in some circles. Trying to get ahead of the curve on that one, the Senators were quick to point out:
Each card's unique biometric identifier would be stored only on the card; no government database would house everyone's information. The cards would not contain any private information, medical information or tracking devices.
Given how stormy the last time immigration reform was raised and given the hard feelings generated by the healthcare battle, it would not seem like an auspicious time.

Still stranger things have happened and if the bipartisan spirit continues, with even a low level of Republican support in the Senate, there should have a fighting chance for reform.

However, it should be remembered that this is an issue which does not necessarily divide only along partisan lines, but also has a geographic element.  Even more importantly, there is a long way between agreement on concepts and agreement on final language of a bill. And just like biometric cards, the pathway to citizenship is a concept that will be a non-starter for many.

I don't think President Obama needs to set aside any days in the near future for a signing ceremony, but it certainly is an interesting start.

Thursday, 25 March 2010

5th Circuit En Banc Request on Smith v. Xerox, Please!

A three judge panel of the 5th Circuit yesterday divided sharply on a case that poses a number of interesting legal issues of great importance for discrimination and retaliation cases in the 5th Circuit. It cries out for an en banc review. Smith v. Xerox Corp. (5th Cir. 3/24/10) [pdf].

Among the issues decided:
  • the Gross analysis is not applicable to Title VII retaliation cases;
  • that a case seemingly tried on a pretext basis will support a mixed motive submission, and plaintiff is not forced to concede that there is some valid basis for termination in order to obtain a mixed motive instruction; and
  • where there was good evidence of the basis for the termination decision, and no real focus on the subjective intent of the managers making the termination decision, there was insufficient evidence to support a $250,000 punitive damage award.
Although Xerox lost on the first two points, it did prevail on the third in a monetarily big way, so either side could be asking for additional review, or both sides might decide they were better off with their victory. I could certainly see the arguments for each position.

But as a bystander unhampered by any stake in the outcome, I see this as a case where all three are extremely important practical issues,  particularly the second one, where the trial bench and bar really need clear guidance.

Judge Jolly, who dissented from the opinion written by Judge Reavley, joined by Judge Wiener, had the following to say about that issue:
Smith’s entire claim in this case was presented to the jury as pretext. Smith alleged that every reason given by Xerox for her termination was pretext  for age and gender discrimination or, alternatively, pretext for retaliating against her because of her EEOC charge. Smith did not argue or acknowledge that the reasons for her discharge were valid; she argued that the employer’s reasons were pretextual, i.e., false, an illegal sham. And, both with respect to discrimination and retaliation, the jury was instructed accordingly: “If you disbelieve the reason(s) Defendant has given for its decision, [i.e., pretext,] you may infer Defendant terminated Plaintiff because she engaged in protected activity.” In short, if discrimination in an alleged mixed-motive case must be shown by pretext, it is not a mixed-motive case at all, it is a pretext case. It should be that short and simple.
In an important footnote in that paragraph, Judge Jolly noted, "we have long required plaintiffs who ask for a mixed-motive instruction to acknowledge the employer’s legitimate motives for discharge," a requirement now expressly disavowed by the majority.

On the other issue that Judge Jolly took issue with, the applicability of the Gross analysis, he wrote:
The majority disagrees, however, asserting the lame distinction that, although the language is identical, Gross was an age discrimination case under the ADEA and the case today is a retaliation case under Title VII. Given the uniform principle set out in Gross, the majority’s distinction is the equivalent of saying that a principle of negligence law developed in the wreck of a green car does not apply to a subsequent case because the subsequent car is red—a meaningless distinction indeed.
Given the clear divide, and the importance, en banc, please!

Update (4.21.10): En banc review is not going to happen. The most recent entry on the docket sheet is a 4/19 letter to the court transmitting a joint Satisfaction and Release of Judgment filed with the district court on 4/19. That pleading states that Xerox has satisfied the original judgment, less the vacated punitive damages, in the amount of $208,159.03.  Impossible to argue with the business decision, but it is a shame that there is no clarification of the opinion.

Tired of Card Check, Rapid Elections? Harv Prof Offers a Different Approach

Benjamin I. Sachs, an Assistant Professor of Law at Harvard has a recent Harvard Law Review article evaluating card check and rapid elections, and suggesting that neither is the optimal approach. Enabling Employee Choice: A Structural Approach to the Rules of Union Organizing.

Before employers get excited that there is yet another potential academic convert to the anti-EFCA movement, it would be helpful to note a couple of items in Professor Sachs' resume -- a clerkship with Judge Reinhardt of the 9th Circuit and a stint in the legal counsel's office of the SEIU.

Given that background it is not surprising that he finds:
The central question raised by EFCA, therefore, is whether enabling employees to limit or avoid managerial intervention in union campaigns is an appropriate goal for federal law. This Article answers this foundational question in the affirmative.
His two proposed solutions would keep secret ballots, but would both require a process of continuous voting that would be conducted without the employer explicitly being told that an election was in process.

While, those ideas are radically different from the current method, if you pose and answer the "central question" as Professor Sachs does, they do follow.

And although there could be much interesting discussion about those suggestions, Professor Sachs, may really, intentionally or not, have raised the real elephant in the room:
What is the policy of the United States with respect to unionization of the work place?
Some would argue that the policy is clearly articulated in §151(d) of the National Labor Relations Act :
It is declared to be the policy of the United States to eliminate the causes of certain substantial obstructions to the free flow of commerce and to mitigate and eliminate these obstructions when they have occurred by encouraging the practice and procedure of collective bargaining and by protecting the exercise by workers of full freedom of association, self- organization, and designation of representatives of their own choosing, for the purpose of negotiating the terms and conditions of their employment or other mutual aid or protection. (emphasis added)
In other words, a pro-union position. But, I think many would be surprised to hear that was the official U.S. policy, and would believe, if it were in fact true, that the real question should be:
What should the policy of the United States be with respect to unionization of the workplace?
Is the answer the same as when the Wagner Act was adopted in 1935, or even when it was modified by the Taft-Hartley Act of 1947? 

EFCA, although discussed in terms of procedure, is really just the most recent proxy fight about that basic question.

For me, the next question becomes:  Is it time to address that issue squarely?

In this era when there seems to so little hope of consensus on any controversial issue, it does not seem that it would be particularly helpful.

Still, just because it is a difficult question, does not mean that it does not exist.

Wednesday, 24 March 2010

5th Circuit to Hear Katrina Related FLSA Labor Case En Banc

Yesterday the 5th Circuit announced it would hear Castellanos-Contrera v. Decatur Hotels en banc.

The case turns on whether an employer who brought foreign workers in post-Katrina  under the H-2B visa program was required to reimburse them for recruitment, transportation and visa expenses in order to meet requirement that wages be paid "free and clear" under the FLSA.

The original panel said no, although it took two opinions to do so. I know that the 5th Circuit has a lot of Katrina related cases that deal with insurance coverage and it may be that there are other H-2B FLSA cases. 

Or maybe a majority of judges just thought the panel got it wrong.

For links to the panel opinon and replacement opinion, see my original post from February 2009.

Tuesday, 23 March 2010

Name, Rank and Serial Number: A Good Policy, But You Have to Follow It

That's the message I would take from the latest MDV report. Credit Agricole was sued by a former employee, William Raedle, who alleged that his former supervisor cost him a job as a financial analyst when he told Raedle's potential employer that he had "mental issues" and what the BusinessWeekarticle refers to as "other disparaging remarks," including difficulty working with others. Credit Agricole Loses Trial Over Poor Job Reference.

The net result a $2.4 million dollar verdict from a New York federal jury that deliberated for just 5 hours following a week long trial.

Of course, if anyone knows that a verdict is not the same as money it is Mr. Raedle, as an earlier trial had also resulted in a favorable verdict, but it had been set aside by the District Judge, who said allowing it to stand would result in a "serious injustice".

It is unclear from the article exactly what the what the legal cause of action that was the basis of Raedle's complaint. Although in this situation it is often defamation, here it appears it could have been tortious interference with a potential business relationship.

What is also clear is that Credit Agricole, like many companies, had a policy that was only to confirm that a person had been employed there, without giving a performance evaluation.

Writing a policy is rarely the hard part; implementation, every day by every one, is.  Some days, it is a million dollar problem.

Update 4.16.10: As a good illustration that a jury verdict is just a step along the way to what ultimately an employer will have to pay and what an employee and their attorney will actually receive, the trial court this week granted judgment as a matter of law to the defendants on the punitive damage award, striking $800,000. However, the other side of the story, the Court has not ruled on plaintiff's request for approximately $609,000 in costs and attorneys fees.  I would  be surprised if there are not other motions pending by the defendant that could ultimately impact other portions of the award as well. And, of course when the trial court finally enters its judgment, there's always the appeal. See $2.4M Award For Ex-Credit Agricole Analyst Trimmed, at Employment Law 360.  ($)